Generation 5

Which Isaac married Kate Sharp??

David 3 and Abigail (Parke) McWithey had sons Reuben 4, Simeon 4, and Isaac 4. David 3 had gone from Connecticut to Dutchess County New York, then into Washington County New York; his sons with him.

Isaac4 had a son Isaac 5 who was bpt. 1785 (birthdate unknown--4 of Isaac's children were bpt. 1785).
Simeon had a son Isaac 5, probably the Isaac born 1755-1774 who was 1800 in Fair Haven Vt. (as was Simeon). They are in the census under the name McWeva.

One of these Isaac5's married Kate Sharp. We know that Isaac and Kate (Sharp) McWithey had these children:

This family was from Fair Haven Vt.
See THE HISTORY OF FAIR HAVEN VT. BY A. ADAMS (published 1870)
p.22: talks about the settlement by Abraham Sharp, a Dutch settler on the NY side...who came with his brother in law James Van Dozen...from near
Bennington...
p.24 refers to Abraham Sharp of Charlotte (now Washington) Co. NY.
(both Simeon 4 and Isaac 4 were in Washington Co .NY, but I believe that only Simeon went into Fair Haven. He went with his father in law, and his son Isaac was in Fair Haven too. This does not mean his nephew Isaac was not there at some point too., though., but I have no evidence that there were two Isaacs in Fair Haven. )
p.24 Abraham Sharp m. Jemimah Van Dozer...he was drowned on a hunting excursion near Granville (Washington Co) NY previous to March 1789...
p.25 James Van Dozer, the brother in law of Mr. Sharp, purchased land..1782...settled and improved this land...Tradition reports that it was occupied by his son in law, Simeon McWithey, called by the old people McQuivey, who lived in a log house. Mr. Van Dozer and his wife were old people and died in their place at an early day. He willed...some land to his grandson Isaac McWithey...rest to Simeon and Sarah McWithey.
p.462(more on this family in book) Abraham Sharp married Jemima VanDozer had sons: Abraham, James, Dreese, Stephen, John ; had daus Hannah, Polly, Speedy, Kate m. Isaac McWithey, Nellie who married John Blighton and Jemimah.
p.434 re: Isaac McWithey. Some say he married Kate Sharp, others say Loraine Church. He is said to have died on Scotch Hill. His children --Simeon, Huldah, Elsie, Almira.
The Isaac who married Kate Sharp did not have children Simeon, Huldah, Elsie and Almira.
Levi McWithey, son of Simeon and Sarah, married a Lorinda Church, but their children were not named Simeon, Huldah etc. either. They went to Pavillion , NY and their family is well documented.

I AM GOING TO PLACE ISAAC WHO M. KATE SHARP AS SON OF SIMEON. BUT PROOF IS STILL NEEDED.